Six officers fired at least 59 shots in less than a minute, killing a man who had roamed his Tennessee neighborhood with a rifle and was looking to commit ”suicide by cop,” authorities said Tuesday.
Chattanooga police Chief Freeman Cooper told radio station WGOW on Tuesday that his officers acted properly in the face of threats by 32-year-old Alonzo Heyward.
”They only fired when they were presented with a threat,” he said.
A police dashboard camera with audio showed that all the shots were fired in three volleys within 30 seconds, Cooper said. The gunfire interrupted as officers repeated commands for Heyward to drop the rifle. Cooper said the simultaneous reactions of all six officers shows they acted properly.
”We are saying that our people did what we trained them to do,” Cooper added.
He did not immediately return phone calls from The Associated Press.
I’ve argued before that police are humans, first and foremost. Like any one of us, they experience fear, nervousness, stress, and any number of debiliating emotions. Robocops, I assure you, they are not. While they may refer to their badges as “shields”, pieces of metal certainly don’t protect cops from succumbing to said emotions while on the job.
Still, there is something grotesque in hearing about officers who spray a lone individual close to sixty times; and with semi-automatic firearms no less (for the uninitiated, semi-automatic weapons only fire off one round of ammuntion each time the trigger is squeezed. So in this case, an average of ten squeezes per offficer took place). In a scene of excessive force mirroring the now infamous stories of Amadou Diallo, Sean Bell, and many others, we now have even more evidence to suggest that police are clearly too trigger happy. The unfortunate consequence of itchy trigger fingers and unbalanced emotions in the corpse of yet another bullet-riddled victim.
One one hand, I can at least maintain that shootings like these are statistically aberrant. For every officer involved in an excessive shooting, I suspect there are many others who have never even drawn their weapon. But the problem is: once one or two officers start getting trigger happy, it has a contagious effect on officers around them. In what some social scientists are calling “contagious shootings” officers tend to discharge their weapon at a much more elevated rate when shooting in groups. Again, a prime example of how police are human. Exhibitions of reflexive and contagious reactions (no doubt propogated by fear, confusion, and perhaps some level of inflated, self-prescribed authority) don’t simply stop once a person becomes a sworn officer. Fortunately, Skip Gates learned this without getting shot to death.
Still, humanity alone can’t justify these demonstrations of excessive force. If trained officers are unable to subdue suspects without clearing out entire magazines, perhaps police work is not for them. In addition to the authority men and women receive when they are awarded with badges, there is also a great deal of responsibility that comes with the job. They are not given a charge to go out and pop everything that moves; doing so with a ten shot per man minimum. The officers in this case have clearly went overboard, emotionally driven or not. They should be made examples of. But with the ever-increasing history of excessive force and aqcuittals, I’m certainly not holding my breath.
What say you?
– ACL
In typical fashion, the media (and apparently you) are quick to make judgements on what happened. Instead of seeing this as a situation where police were trying to protect innocent people, it has become a crusade against the police. I’m waiting for Obama to say these police were acting stupidly.
If my memory serves me correctly, the original article stated the subject was “suicidal”. So would this not be a simple case of “suicide by cop” as has been the case many times before?
Excessive? Maybe. However, I don’t even want to imagine what COULD have happened to innocent people had the police not responded. At the end of the day, NOBODY knows what happened. Only those at ‘the scene’ know what took place, how it all came about, and why it ended the way it did.
Second-guessing, undue criticism, and rush to judgment can be nearly as deadly as all those bullets. Be sure of your target before you fire.
If somebody is going to roam around their neighborhood wielding a rifle looking for “suicide by cop”, then they’re going to find it. It’s as simple as that. Furthermore, if these shots were in fact fired in three separate volleys with commands to drop his weapon being ignored between each volley, then I don’t see what the problem is. Nut-jobs like this get absolutely zero sympathy from me.
-Don’t walk around your neighborhood w/ a rifle looking for trouble.
-If ordered by the police to drop your weapon, do so.
-If shot by the police, & you really want to live, refer to the above.
-n
Although the provided link contains it, you left out a fairly important detail…
“Weary said the officers followed Heyward as he walked from a restaurant parking lot to the porch of his house, then unsuccessfully attempted to subdue him with a stun gun. They shot him when he refused to drop the rifle and pointed it, police said.”
The guy couldn’t just take a few bullets & keep going (an amazing feat by itself), but unless the Officers missed w/ the stun gun, was able to take that as well. So, seeing how this guy was waving & pointing a .44 Magnum rifle (which is capable of creating a hole in somebody nearly the size of my fist) I am incredibly curious as to what you would’ve done had you been put in the position of any of the officers Andre. It’s easy to say that 59 shots are excessive due to the sheer number, but not so much when you’ve already put a few through somebody & that person is still pointing a .44 caliber gun @ you.
-n
Uh…one person, 59 shots. How is that NOT excessive?
When after 58 shots the guy pointing a gun @ you is still standing & pointing a gun @ you.
-n
Andre, I remember how you were “silently cheering” (as you put it), when a Texas cop tasered a 72 year old woman. I’m curious to see how you’ll respond to this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xW_-bSxTyI
More police brutality caught on tape. When will it stop?
Sweet & innocent ol’ grannie…wielding a knife in a public parking lot.
-Don’t walk around a parking lot w/ a knife looking for trouble.
-If ordered by the police to drop your knife, do so.
I fail to see how this isn’t common knowledge in today’s world.
-n
Hey Dre,
I admit it seems excessive to shoot someone that many times. However, you walk around drunk and armed, refuse to drop your weapon, point it at the police and then get shot-IT’S YOUR OWN DAMN FAULT! No one else’s. 50 shots or 50,000, it still YOUR FAULT. Maybe you could explain something to me I don’t understand about these gun posts. What I got out of your last two posts is as follows;
White nut with gun =worthless blemish on society and stereotypical of gun owners.
Black nut with gun = victim
Now I have a couple of questions.
1) Does the color of your skin automatically absolve you from being a “gun nut” ? (I’ve never, ever heard a black person with a collection of guns refered to that way.)
2) If the man in the previous post was shot 50 times would he then be a victim of overzealous police?
3) If the man in this post would have shot and killed a cop first, then would it be O.K. to shoot him 50 times? If not, what is the proper number?
4) Is it equally bad (or worse) for a black cop to shoot a black man? How about a white man?